Listen Live!
join BAW
forgot password
LIFE
WORK
PLAY


blAck americaweb.com

Commentary: By Keeping Nagin in Office, Big Easy Blacks Were Making a Larger Statement

Date: Sunday, May 21, 2006
By: Deborah Mathis, BlackAmericaWeb.com

I met the man a few weeks ago in a FEMA trailer park in New Orleans. Like everyone else there, he had a sad story to tell, but his was one of those you can’t forget.

He lost both his home and his job in Hurricane Katrina. His 60-year-old sister lost even more.

As this fellow told it, his sister not only lost her home and all that she owned, but her daughter as well. A few days before the storm, the daughter had a cyst removed from her arm. Shortly after Katrina, the young woman was helping a neighbor clean up the storm damage when she came in contact with toxic water, which then set up a vicious infection in her arm that spread throughout her body. She died, leaving behind the two children she had been rearing with her second husband.  The children’s biological father, a reported reprobate, showed up to reclaim the children he had long ignored. Now he won’t let the children see their grandmother.

According to the man at the trailer park, his sister cries everyday.

“None of this is right,” he complained. “Every single thing -- from the warning to the evacuation to the fact that we’re going to have to start getting our own propane soon -- all of it is wrong. We’re all good people here, and we were all let down. By everybody.”

Yet, when asked about the then-impending mayoral election, the man said he was going to vote for Ray Nagin, the incumbent and, as such, part of the “everybody” whose judgment calls have been blamed for the Crescent City’s continuing sorry state.

“I was mad as hell at first,” the man said. “But, now I know he probably did the best he could. Nobody could have done anything different, really.”

It must be true, then, that time heals all wounds, because, three months ago, most observers -- inside and out -- wouldn’t have given Nagin a snowball’s chance in hell of winning re-election. The evacuees, the political establishment and the city’s elite were all fed up with him; the news media was perplexed. 

One minute, Hizzoner was blasting George W. Bush and the feds with almost unheard-of candor and bluntness; the next minute, he was touring with Bush and expressing good faith.

Another minute, Nagin seemed to be more interested in commercialism than community, the next, he was the people’s prince.

One minute, he was extolling the return of a “chocolate city,” the next he was backpedaling with some balderdash about a vanilla blend.

Meanwhile, the almost solidly black and low-income Lower Ninth Ward decayed even further, barely touched by clean-up crews and still occasionally yielding a rotting body in some upturned house in the middle of the street. And the people who used to live there languish still in trailer parks, tent villages, motel rooms, borrowed apartments or relatives’ homes as far away as Seattle.

But, make no mistake: There was more than forgiveness behind Nagin’s victory over Lt. Gov. Mitch Landrieu in Saturday’s election. And there was more than hope at play. There was a political statement being made too -- namely, that the citizens of a majority black city were not about to relinquish what power they had to a white man.

“Whenever folks say that it’s not about race, it ends up being about race,” said my friend, Monica Pierre, a wildly popular media maven in New Orleans. “For some blacks, the election became more about battling the perceived power grab by whites bent on electing a white mayor.”

It’s not that no black New Orleanians voted for Landrieu; of course some did, as the lieutenant governor’s family has long enjoyed popular support among blacks, who helped put the candidate’s father, the late Moon Landrieu, in the mayor’s seat and his sister, Mary, in the U.S. Senate.  Besides, as Pierre suggests, many black voters were embarrassed by and disappointed in Nagin.

But, as Pierre points out, “It was more important for African-Americans to be the deciding factor on who gets elected.”

If this reading is right, and I think it is, Nagin has his work cut out for him. He owes his political survival to people who came through for him even though he has yet to return the favor. 

Ray Nagin would be wise to remember that and to walk humbly from now on. He has more to rebuild than just streets and structures.




Discuss

Nolaviolet says:

Moon Landrieu is not deceased as the article states

gratefullyso says:

That big head kid Ray Jr. in the background! Both daddy and Jr. really need hair on top of those read more

khrishill says:

I can't find my post.

khrishill says:

I am glad to see that someone realizes that he was new in his role when disaster hit.

read more

wb6674 says:

What happened to all the lobbying to get the vote pushed back or not counting since people of LA had read more

More Headlines

Commentary: Hopefully, ‘The Wire’ Star Who Got Tripped Up Will Realize the Idiocy in the ‘No Snitching’ Mentality

Boy, talk about life imitating art that was imitating life. Felicia "Snoop" Pearson, who played a homicidal character on "The Wire," is back in jail.

Commentary: One Thing Monday Night’s Speech Set Straight for Sure? Michelle Obama is No ‘Baby Mama’

Michelle Obama is no baby mama. But let's hope that the real baby mamas, and for that matter, the baby daddies, were tuned in Monday night -- and taking notes.

Commentary: Sorry, Charlie – Despite Her Supporters, There’s No Way Hillary Could’ve Got the V.P. Offer

It could not have been Hillary Clinton. In far too many instances, the Hillary camp crossed the narrow strait between competitiveness and contempt.

Guest Commentary: By Changing Football as the Players’ Union Head, Upshaw Changed the Game in More Ways than One

A NFL star performer for 15 years with the Oakland Raiders and a Hall of Famer in the aftermath, Gene Upshaw should be remembered as a caretaker.

Commentary: Brothers with Real Power in Hollywood Should Be Flexing Their Muscles on Behalf of the Sisters

Audiences are being cheated of seeing some very fine black talent on the screen, just as, years ago, we were cheated of seeing Judy Pace as often as we should have.

Commentary: For Dozens of Million-Dollar Companies Contracting Prison Workers, Crime Really Does Pay

Inmates are now doing manufacturing chores and other tasks for corporations who have, undoubtedly, found a way to profit from America’s prison explosion.

Commentary: Barack Obama Can’t Win as Long as He Continues to Play That Tired, Dog-Eared Race Card

Rather than representing a new kind of politics, Obama appears to be not so different from any number of liberal black politicians who've graced the stage.



Copyright © 2001-2005 BlackAmericaWeb.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
About Us | Advertise | Help | Privacy Policy | Search | Terms of Use | Unsubscribe