Listen Live!
join BAW
forgot password
LIFE
WORK
PLAY


blAck americaweb.com

Commentary: Can the Passion Over Schiavo Be Applied to the Well Being of the Vitally Alive?

Date: Sunday, March 27, 2005
By: Deborah Mathis, BlackAmericaWeb.com

Even after weeks of drama over the fate of Terri Schiavo – the extraordinary measure taken by the U.S. Congress, the Florida governor and Legislature’s attempts to intervene; the spectacle of protestors around the Florida hospice where Schiavo languishes – the society appears no closer to consensus about end-of-life issues than before.

Polls may show that most people believe the government has no business nosing in on such personal matters, but there are enough out there who think such intrusion is not only right but also righteous – the kind of thing that separates true believes from fakes, agnostics and atheists.

According to the die-hards, the decision to remove Terri’s feeding tube and allow her to die smacks of playing God.  They proposed, instead, to keep the severely brain-damaged woman in her pitiful state until either her organs fail on their own or God presents a miracle, which it certainly would be considering that much of Terri’s brain has disintegrated into jelly or liquid.

I, for one, believe in miracles. But God also endowed us with certain powers of our own and that, I submit, includes the power to decide when enough’s enough.  It is no more playing God to let nature take its course in ending life than it is to take pain relievers, have an operation, undergo dialysis or have Lasix surgery to sustain or prolong or improve life’s quality. Where are the “playing God” protests over Viagra, for example?

In both instances, it can be argued that God provided the curiosity and resources that led to the wisdom and the science that keeps us ticking longer or better. It is hardly playing God to take advantage of scientific discovery.

Granted, the instruments of Terri Schiavo’s demise – starvation and dehydration – seem cruel, even if she is not suffering, as some doctors insist.  But, the irony is that some of the same objectors to the feeding tube removal are responsible for the absence of a more humane method of letting her go.  Thanks to prohibitions against euthanasia, Terri could not be allowed to simply drift off into that deep sleep.

Had there been a kinder, gentler way to handle the poor woman’s end, it would have still been a wrenching decision. No parent wants to know that his or her child is dying, let alone have a hand in the process. 

The fight between Terri’s parents, the Schindlers, and her husband is the stuff of family feuds and breakdowns galore.  Even if there were proof that the woman opposed being artificially supported, it would still be a heartbreaking choice to pull the plug. The last thing anyone needs at a time like that is a political firestorm and other outside pressures from people who do not, and can not, know the nuances of family dynamics.

Again, the one conclusion the society has apparently reached is that government does not belong in matters so intensely and painfully personal.  It’s the reason abortion has remained legal despite ferocious lobbying to outlaw it; a woman’s womb is not the place for political posturing.

If only there were as much passion applied to the well being of the vitally alive.  How about a few sit-ins for quality medical care for all of those poor children with earaches and asthma whose health is still salvageable?  How about a midnight vote on Capitol Hill to give relief to senior citizens who still can’t afford life-saving prescriptions, discount card or no?

How about government putting its nose where it belongs – in public policy to benefit the common good – and keep it out of those private confines where mothers, fathers, husbands and wives – and God – know best?




Discuss

Premed06 says:

Well the difference between brain dead and damaged is this. When you are brain dead, there is N-O brain read more

FvOoh says:

Why now? This has been going on for at least ten years. She has been in this condition for fifteen. read more

Verne1111 says:

I told my family, Y'all had better feed me and jump up and down on my chest, if necessary, read more

Verne1111 says:

I told my family, Y'all had better feed me and jump up and down on my chest, if necessary, read more

EMONIQUE989 says:

4. For those who think this a humane way to die, I want you to set up a calendar and read more

More Headlines

Commentary: Their V.P. Nominee’s Kin Proves the Hypocrisy of Republicans’ Stance on Sex Education

When Sen. John McCain named Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin as his running mate, he helped expose the deep hypocrisies of the Republican party.

Commentary: Trust Me, Republicans, Going After Obama for His ‘Terrorist Ties’ is a Very Bad Idea

A word of advice to my fellow Republicans: You don't want to make an issue of Sen. Barack Obama’s friendship with William Ayers. That wouldn't be wise.

Commentary: If Politics Isn’t Child’s Play, Why Should Sarah Palin Get the Kid-Gloves Treatment?

It seems there’s a lot more drama tucked into the resume of GOP vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin than rank-and-file Republicans were led to believe.

Commentary: On Kids’ Achievement Gap, Biden May Have Been Correct Before He Became Politically Correct

The Delaware senator didn't mean to imply that black students were inherently academically inferior to their white and Asian counterparts. Or did he?

Commentary: Hopefully, ‘The Wire’ Star Who Got Tripped Up Will Realize the Idiocy in the ‘No Snitching’ Mentality

Boy, talk about life imitating art that was imitating life. Felicia "Snoop" Pearson, who played a homicidal character on "The Wire," is back in jail.

Commentary: One Thing Monday Night’s Speech Set Straight for Sure? Michelle Obama is No ‘Baby Mama’

Michelle Obama is no baby mama. But let's hope that the real baby mamas, and for that matter, the baby daddies, were tuned in Monday night -- and taking notes.

Commentary: Sorry, Charlie – Despite Her Supporters, There’s No Way Hillary Could’ve Got the V.P. Offer

It could not have been Hillary Clinton. In far too many instances, the Hillary camp crossed the narrow strait between competitiveness and contempt.



Copyright © 2001-2005 BlackAmericaWeb.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
About Us | Advertise | Help | Privacy Policy | Search | Terms of Use | Unsubscribe