Listen Live!
join BAW
forgot password
LIFE
WORK
PLAY


blAck americaweb.com

Guest Commentary: California Supreme Court’s Ruling on Gay Marriage a Benefit to Everyone

Date: Friday, May 16, 2008
By: H. Alexander Robinson, Special to BlackAmericaWeb.com

Yesterday, the California Supreme Court handed down a historic decision upholding the freedom granting hundreds of thousands of residents in the state of California the freedom to marry the person they love.

The state Supreme Court ruled in favor of legalizing unions between people of the same gender, thus affirming decades of progress made within the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender movement in the state of California.

The second state high court to rule in favor of ending the exclusion of same-sex couples from marriage said “in view of the substance and significance of the fundamental constitutional right to form a family relationship, the California Constitution properly must be interpreted to guarantee this basic civil right [marriage] to all Californians, whether gay or heterosexual, and to same-sex couples as well as to opposite-sex couples.”






Having grown up in the segregated south, I have witnessed and experienced discrimination, and I have witnessed and experienced progress, understanding and change. This decision is a crucial step in realizing the vision of one America, an America that is no longer divided by race, gender or sexual orientation.

Today we stand at a pivotal point in history. As a black community, we have the unique opportunity of ushering in a new era of social change and progress for another oppressed group.

The shameful history of discrimination faced by African-Americans is virtually unparalleled in our country. However, discrimination in all its forms is simply wrong and must never be tolerated within our society. To tolerate injustice and discrimination toward gay Americans threatens the very justice for which so many Americans gave their lives.

To not have the right to visit a partner in the hospital, inherit each other’s assets or even be able to draw medical insurance from a spouse’s policy is a heartbreaking tragedy that gay men and women must face as a daily reality. It is only through the civil rights of a “marriage” and not a civil union which provides over 1,000 federal benefits to prevent these disparities from happening.

As black people, we know from our own civil rights history that change does not happen overnight, but instead happens over duration of time.

As we celebrate the memory of our recently departed champion Mildred Loving, let us not forget that it was just 41 years ago next month that the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in the Loving vs. State of Virginia decision, one that allowed interracial marriage across every state in the nation.

We must never take for granted the institution of marriage. It is a sacred expression of love. Regardless of who you love, the rights to marry should always be an option.

Many object to marriage for same gender couples based on history or religious beliefs. Two things are clear. First, the Court’s ruling only applies to the civil institution of marriage, and our churches and mosques will remain free to celebrate the unions of their choice.

Second, the court, in citing its ruling 60 years ago in Perez v. Sharp -- which found that “notwithstanding the circumstances that statutory prohibitions on interracial marriage had existed since the founding of the state -- makes clear that history alone is not invariably an appropriate guide for determining the meaning and cope of this fundamental (state) constitutional guarantee.”

The National Black Justice Coalition and the California Conference of the NAACP filed an amicus in support of the rights of same gender couples to marry in the state. Now the forces of bigotry and discrimination will seek to overturn this ruling by writing discrimination into the California constitution. We must stand against the forces that stand on the wrong side of history.

We must stand against these forces in every state in the union, as there are multiple ballot initiatives, pending state legislation and court cases waiting to be heard such is the case in the state of Florida.

Finally, we should reflect upon the words of Willie L. Brown Jr., the former mayor of San Francisco, who stated that “The African-American community has been at the forefront of many struggles to secure rights for disenfranchised groups and communities. On the issue of marriage equality, however, we have not used our voices or resources to mobilize affirmatively. For the most part, we have been silent. It is my belief that this is our fight too. We must stand for equality and dignity for all of our brothers and sisters. The right to marry whomever you choose is a right that should be enjoyed by everyone.”

---

H. Alexander Robinson is executive director and CEO of the National Black Justice Coalition, America’s only nationwide black lesbian, gay, bisexual and trangender civil rights organization.




Discuss

Soulsonsix says:

There are a lot of compelling arguments about the article and the supposed benefit derived by the ruling it discusses. read more

tgn512 says:

THE BIBLE SAY THAT "ALL HAVE SINNED AND COME SHORT OF THE GLORY OF GOD".THAT INCLUDES YOU ALSO.YOU read more

jazflutesmith says:

Hispanics are slowly and methodically keeping their families pretty much intact, better than black Americans. Blacks are now the SECOND read more

jazflutesmith says:

This maybe a prejudicial statement. Black females have always accepted black gay men in the church. Black men just ignored read more

jazflutesmith says:

are just as rotten as garbage in a dumpster off Broadway. Every religion justifies its' dirt so eloquently and so read more

  web blackamericaweb.com
Google




More Headlines

Is Media Playing Fair in Campaign Coverage?

Television news' royalty will fly in to meet Barack Obama during this week's overseas trip: CBS chief anchor Katie Couric in Jordan on Tuesday, ABC's Charles Gibson in Israel on Wednesday and NBC' ...

The Hutchinson Report: Forget Apologizing to Obama -- Jackson Should Apologize to Blacks for His N-Word Hypocrisy

Listeners to Jesse Jackson’s national radio program should consider a brief boycott of the show to convey that the N-word is offensive, even when he utters it.

The Hutchinson Report: Democrats in Sudden, Election Year Rush to Dump the Permanent Felon Voting Ban

For decades, there has been no sustained move by legislators to scrap the ban on felons voting -- until now. Lifting it will clearly boost the Democrats.

The Hutchinson Report: Shock Jock Don Imus Should Apologize to Blacks for His Latest Racial Insult

Imus' crack on his nationally syndicated WABC morning talk show reinforces the worst racial stereotypes of crime and violence about African-Americans.



Copyright © 2001-2005 BlackAmericaWeb.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
About Us | Advertise | Help | Privacy Policy | Search | Terms of Use | Unsubscribe