Defenders of Post Cartoon Prove That Eric Holder Was Right

Date: Wednesday, February 25, 2009, 6:02 am
By: Tonyaa Weathersbee, BlackAmericaWeb.com

Bookmark and Share

Attorney General Eric Holder signs autographs after making remarks commemorating Black History Month. (AP)

So now, it seems the defenders of the New York Post’s despicable chimpanzee cartoon have veered way off the path of common sense and context to find a scapegoat.

They did some reaching and came up with … Eric Holder.

The nation’s new attorney general recently shook the realm of right-wing punditry and denial-ridden citizens by saying, during a Black History Month speech to Justice Department employees, that Americans needed to have more honest dialogue with each other regarding race and to understand the history of black folks in the United States.

“Though this nation has proudly thought of itself as an ethnic melting pot, in things racial, we have always been and continue to be, in too many ways, essentially a nation of cowards," Holder said.

Holder should have known better.

He should have known that calling Americans cowards on the unfinished business of racial equality and on the frank discussion of racial matters, especially when so many of them voted for President Barack Obama and literally believe this county is the “home of the brave,” would set off a lot of folks.

For many people, historical truth is no match for patriotic hype.

But now, some pundits are using Holder’s bluntness to defend what amounted to a racial slur splashed on the New York Post’s editorial page. Cartoonist Sean Delonas recently drew a cartoon of two police officers who had filled a chimpanzee full of bullets – with a caption saying that “They'll have to find someone else to write the next stimulus bill.”

The Post initially issued a half-hearted apology, and defended the chimpanzee as symbolic of Congress, not Obama. The Post’s owner, News Corp magnate Rupert Murdoch, today issued a stronger apology.
 
But scores of black people, many of whom remember a time when some whites thought they had monkey tails and how even today, know that police use slurs such as “porch monkeys,” and “gorillas in the midst,” to denigrate them, aren’t buying the Post’s explanation.
 
And, for that matter, neither are a lot of whites.

So the Post has been inundated with complaints and picketers. The NAACP has demanded the firings of the editor and Delonas, and the Rev. Al Sharpton is calling for a boycott.

And the commotion over that, say the cartoon’s defenders, is precisely why the country will never be able to speak frankly about race. If white folks say the wrong thing, some pundits argue, they will be labeled as racists. The way they see it, if white folks are cowards, it’s only because black folks are bad sports.

What hooey.

First of all, the people who are using Holder’s words as an excuse to defend the cartoon are guilty of the same kind of racial arrogance that keeps racism alive. If thousands of people, black and white, saw racism in the cartoon, then that means something is wrong.

At that point, it makes more sense to try to understand why that cartoon offended so many, rather than defend it.

Like Holder said, it’s time to talk.

Secondly, the Post’s cartoon debacle, if anything, is precisely the reason why more black people and white people ought to stop shying away from confronting the subject of race. Had the Post had any black editors or blacks in higher management to look at that cartoon, or if Delonas had spent any time at all talking to or absorbing the history of any real black folks, he would have known that such a cartoon was going to spark outrage.

In other words, if more whites and blacks were having honest conversations about race, there would be fewer transgressions like the one committed by the Post – because .....


Bookmark and Share
Please Login or Register to Rate this article



Please Login or Register to post comments on this article

  |   Read More Comments





Re: ".. please help me understand why you would call someone "N" in the first place." The "N" word has not and probably won't disappear from my vocabulary. I don't use iit as a term of endearment. It's the only appropriate word to capture the ignorant, cesspool level of mentality and behavior some members of our race exhibit. When Black folks act like n!ggaz, the word "nigga" rises once again from that shallow grave we buried it in last year ... Jason in the umpteenth sequel to those Friday 13th movies


by   
Mandinka_99
February 26, 2009, 1:12 pm
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mkrep,
Try to use JUST A LITTLE intuition & comprehension when you read something, please.

That was sarcasm, devils-advocate, etc. Clearly you are new on this site. I am about as militant as they come, and I’d better NEVER hear a white person use that word.
I was accentuating the article, and the excuses racists make. Sorry you didn’t get it.


by   
Sevennotrump
February 25, 2009, 4:21 pm
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sevennottrump, please help me understand why you would call someone "N" in the first place. I can recall some years ago (more than 20) when a co-worker had gotten mad at someone and shortly afterwards was walking by me and called the person a "N.....B*...". I'm a Black female and the person who made the comment was a white male. I called him on the carpet and let him know that his comment was not appropriate and he responded that he calls all his friends that. (yeah right). I saw the true colors of that person on that day.


by   
Mkrep
February 25, 2009, 1:02 pm
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Neither do we need in racial conversations, white-posers, like this jiggy, who come on Blk sites, trying to pretend they are Black, so they can****ert racist views, and make it seem like its coming from a devout Uncle Tom.
What Blk ADULT is going to call himself, “jiggy”.
We jump on racial slurs, we DO NOT jump on common sense discussions, and it is NOT a SLUR if it’s true, racists just FEEL Blacks are making slurs when we refer to their racist behavior.


by   
Sevennotrump
February 25, 2009, 12:36 pm
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

To a point, they are right, we blacks have a double standard when it comes to racism. We never call out our own slurs or those that play the race card with no basis in fact, but quick to jump whitey on anything remotely color related.


by   
Jiggy5
February 25, 2009, 11:46 am
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
More Headlines
How Did Karrine Steffans Change the World?

Steffans does think she changed the world. She said as much on "Life After."

Parents Must Resist the Whitewashing of History

Our children are vulnerable to the whitewashing of history that right wingers have embarked on.

Analysis: Why Would Obama Listen to Beck?

Obama didn’t watch Glenn Beck’s rally on the National Mall. And for good reason.

What Did Beck Prove? Misery Loves Company

His event had no more power or effect than we chose to assign it.

Obama Walks the Walk on Katrina Recovery

Some black residents in the Big Easy still believe the nation has forgotten them.  

Collum's 'The Black Dragon' Has Lessons Galore

Racial profiling on the New Jersey Turnpike is what "The Black Dragon" is all about.

Ebonics a Language? Thanks for Confirming That

It’s an acknowledgment that comes way too late. And from the wrong place.

Analysis: Obama Measures Up in New Orleans

Even Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal, a Republican, has praised the president's efforts.

Stick to Music, 'Clef, Don’t Play Politics

Wyclef Jean should do what’s best for Haiti: Stop playing politics and get back to his music.

Sorry, Doctor, You Still Can't Say That

Schesslinger’s the kind of white person who thinks they understand black folks.

Career Central
Search millions of job listings from across the web. New jobs added daily!



Post a Job on Black America Web!
advertising
advertising
advertising